An Instacart+ membership costs $9.99/month or $99/year in both the United States and Canada. Without a membership, each delivery carries a delivery fee (this calculator models $5.99 per US order and $6.99 per Canadian order, before service fees and tips); with Instacart+, the delivery fee is $0 on eligible orders over $10 (over $35 at Costco). At those typical fees, the monthly plan pays for itself in about two deliveries a month, and the $99 annual plan in about seventeen deliveries a year in the US (about fifteen in Canada, where the modeled fee is higher).
Instacart+ members also earn 5% credit back on pickup orders, and the membership includes Peacock Premium streaming, with annual members getting partner perks such as NYT Cooking access on top. The calculator below compares the membership fee against your own delivery and pickup habits, because the right answer depends on how often you actually order.
Based on your usage, Instacart+ would save you $6.24 per month. We recommend getting the subscription.
Priced on monthly billing: $9.99 every month.
Based on your usage in United States, Instacart+ appears to be worth the monthly cost. You could save money while enjoying the benefits.
Net saving per month. Full breakdown above.